sellmefear
← all entries

OUTLETS DISAGREEThursday 13 August 2026

Outlets disagree: Tax revenue loss attributed to illegal tobacco products in 2025: anglocelt.ie and westmeathindependent.ie quote JTI Ireland as claiming €1 billion was lost in…

anglocelt.ie states '€1 billion was lost in 2025 alone' and 'The Government's own figures…; westmeathindependent.ie states the same; dundalkdemocrat.ie states '€758 million was lost specifically to illegal tobacco…

As published

7 pages captured at the time, in each outlet's own typography. Open one to read the copy held outside the publisher's control.

What this entry found

  • ONE SOURCE, MANY MASTHEADS

    7 outlets carried this. They resolve to 6 independent sources.

    A reader sampling these outlets received 6 accounts, not 7.

  • ONLY ONE OUTLET HAD THIS

    leinsterleader.ie carried 3 details no other outlet reported.

    • In Naas, 51% of cigarette packs surveyed in 2026 were NIDP, with 14% being counterfeit
    • In Leixlip, 48% of cigarette packs surveyed were NIDP and 16% were counterfeit
    • In Newbridge, 53% of packs surveyed were NIDP and almost one-fifth (19%) were counterfeit
7outlets6independent
What happened, for context

A survey commissioned by JTI Ireland found that 57% of cigarette packs surveyed nationwide in 2026 were non-Irish duty-paid (NIDP), with 14% being counterfeit. The survey, called the Empty Pack Survey, identified significant regional variation, with Galway recording the highest rate at 75% NIDP and Swords at 66%. JTI Ireland claims the state has lost approximately €5 billion in tax revenue to NIDP products since 2018, including €1 billion in 2025.

Who reported it

    • anglocelt.ieUNCLASSIFIED
    • westmeathindependent.ieUNCLASSIFIED
    identical copy
  • dundalkdemocrat.ieUNCLASSIFIED
  • leinsterleader.ieUNCLASSIFIED
  • lmfm.ieUNCLASSIFIED
  • retailnews.ieUNCLASSIFIED
  • roscommonherald.ieUNCLASSIFIED

References

Carried by multiple outlets

  • The Empty Pack Survey found that 57% of cigarette packs surveyed nationwide in Ireland in 2026 were non-Irish duty-paid (NIDP)dundalkdemocrat.ie, leinsterleader.ie, retailnews.ie, roscommonherald.ie
  • Of the NIDP packs, 14% were counterfeit cigarettesdundalkdemocrat.ie, leinsterleader.ie, lmfm.ie, retailnews.ie, roscommonherald.ie
  • The survey was carried out on behalf of JTI Irelanddundalkdemocrat.ie, leinsterleader.ie, lmfm.ie, retailnews.ie, roscommonherald.ie, anglocelt.ie, westmeathindependent.ie
  • Since 2018, the Irish exchequer has lost approximately €5 billion in tax revenue to NIDP productsdundalkdemocrat.ie, leinsterleader.ie, lmfm.ie, retailnews.ie, roscommonherald.ie
  • Around €1 billion was lost in 2025 alonedundalkdemocrat.ie, leinsterleader.ie, lmfm.ie, retailnews.ie, roscommonherald.ie
  • According to Government figures, €758 million was lost specifically to illegal tobacco productsdundalkdemocrat.ie, leinsterleader.ie, lmfm.ie, retailnews.ie, roscommonherald.ie
  • and 7 more, not shown

Reported by one outlet only

  • In Dundalk specifically, 57% of cigarette packs surveyed in 2026 were NIDP, with 17% being counterfeitonly dundalkdemocrat.ie
  • In Drogheda, almost a third (30%) of cigarette packs surveyed were NIDP and 12% were counterfeitonly dundalkdemocrat.ie
  • In Naas, 51% of cigarette packs surveyed in 2026 were NIDP, with 14% being counterfeitonly leinsterleader.ie
  • In Leixlip, 48% of cigarette packs surveyed were NIDP and 16% were counterfeitonly leinsterleader.ie
  • In Newbridge, 53% of packs surveyed were NIDP and almost one-fifth (19%) were counterfeitonly leinsterleader.ie
  • In Navan, 60% of cigarette packs surveyed in 2026 were NIDP, with nearly one-fifth (17%) being counterfeitonly lmfm.ie

Reported unevenly

  • Tax revenue loss attributed to illegal tobacco products in 2025: anglocelt.ie and westmeathindependent.ie quote JTI Ireland as claiming €1 billion was lost in 2025 alone, while also citing Government figures of €750 million in lost taxes in 2025 from illegal tobacco products. Other outlets cite €758 million from Government figures.stated by anglocelt.ie states '€1 billion was lost in 2025 alone' and 'The Government's own figures show that illegal tobacco products cost the state over €750 million in lost taxes in 2025 alone', westmeathindependent.ie states the same, dundalkdemocrat.ie states '€758 million was lost specifically to illegal tobacco products', leinsterleader.ie states '€758m was lost specifically to illegal tobacco products', lmfm.ie states '€758 million was lost specifically to illegal tobacco products', retailnews.ie states '€750 million' initially then '€758 million' in the quote section (unclear which appears), roscommonherald.ie states '€758 million was lost specifically to illegal tobacco products'
  • Counterfeit cigarettes in Dundalk: dundalkdemocrat.ie states 17% of packs surveyed in Dundalk were counterfeit, but states nationwide the figure was 14%. Other outlets consistently state nationwide counterfeit rate at 14% without reporting Dundalk-specific figures.stated by dundalkdemocrat.ie reports 17% counterfeit in Dundalk · absent from leinsterleader.ie, lmfm.ie, retailnews.ie, roscommonherald.ie